Solana has emerged as a robust presence within the crypto trade. Since its inception in 2020, the community has dominated the market, demonstrating outstanding ranges of person engagement and sensible utility, notably in decentralized finance (DeFi). Many within the trade view it as the subsequent pure contender to obtain an ETF approval in america.
Nonetheless, others are extra cautious of their evaluations. BeInCrypto spoke with representatives from Gravity, Variant, and OKX to grasp the areas the place Solana continues to be missing. Business leaders referred to centralization, community reliability, and extreme regulation as factors of rivalry for Solana’s ETF approval.
Bitcoin and Ethereum’s Precedent
The supply of exchange-traded funds (ETFs) for outstanding cryptocurrencies has grown over the previous yr. These funds supply traders diversified funding alternatives and act as a bridge between conventional finance and the more and more mainstream cryptocurrency market.
Bitcoin turned the primary cryptocurrency to have spot ETFs accepted by the US Securities and Change Fee (SEC) in January 2024. The SEC’s approval of 11 such ETFs enabled traders to entry Bitcoin by oblique funding. Final Might, Ethereum intently adopted swimsuit with its personal ETF approval.
Like Bitcoin, this approval proved a vital milestone for the trade . The success of each of these digital belongings in reaching ETF approval after years of trial and error noticed substantial inflows and drove costs to report highs, sparking optimism amongst traders and market analysts.
Solana positions itself to be the subsequent cryptocurrency in line to hunt its very personal ETF approval. Yesterday marked the top of the 240-day overview interval for a number of the first Solana ETF filings, notably from VanEck and 21Shares, which have been filed in mid-2024.
Quickly after the deadline expired, the SEC delayed ETF functions for Solana, XRP, Litecoin, and Dogecoin after dealing with latest criticism for its pro-crypto actions.
In the meantime, the deadline for some filings, together with Grayscale’s, was prolonged till October. Nonetheless, posts on X and a few analytical experiences counsel yesterday’s deadline as a date of curiosity for an preliminary or consolidated SEC response to a number of functions.
2025 Predictions and Market Expectations
The tentative approval of a Solana ETF has generated a lot debate throughout social media platforms. ETF President Nate Geraci formally predicted that 2025 could be the yr of crypto ETFs and that Solana would obtain its approval this yr.
Per earlier experiences, former Trump White Home Secretary Anthony Scaramucci expressed that, with a Trump reelection, Solana ETFs might acquire approval throughout Q1 of 2025. In response to his predictions, Solana would obtain the SEC’s inexperienced gentle through the subsequent two weeks.
In the meantime, the prediction market Polymarket estimates an 82% likelihood {that a} Solana ETF will get accepted in 2025.
A number of components make an imminent Solana ETF approval appear believable. Lower than 5 years after the community launched, Solana rapidly turned a serious participant within the crypto trade, attracting customers for its excessive transaction speeds and low gasoline charges.
“From a community perspective, Solana’s efficiency has been outstanding, now driving practically 50% of all international DEX quantity– a dominance that basically reshapes the DeFi panorama. The blockchain isn’t just dealing with unprecedented transaction volumes… it’s reworking our understanding of blockchain scalability at scale,” Lennix Lai, World Chief Industrial Officer at OKX informed BeInCrypto.
Solana has established itself as a dynamic drive within the crypto trade following a profitable 2024.
A Messari report detailed explicit progress in Solana’s remaining quarter throughout DeFi, liquid staking, NFTs, and institutional involvement. The entire worth locked (TVL) in Solana’s DeFi sector elevated considerably, rising by 64% to $8.6 billion, which positioned it behind Ethereum because the second-largest community based mostly on TVL.
Solana’s constructive efficiency, coupled with Donald Trump’s reelection to the US presidency, additional amplified the crypto trade’s optimism over an ETF approval.
Nonetheless, some trade consultants have expressed extra tempered expectations.
Specialists Provide Tempered Expectations
Just a few days earlier than Trump assumed the presidency, Bloomberg Intelligence analyst James Seyffart stated Solana ETFs will not be launched within the US till 2026. He cited the SEC’s precedent of taking plenty of time to overview filings because the trigger for delay.
In one other submit, Bloomberg Senior ETF analyst Eric Balchunas stated that ETF approvals for different cryptocurrencies have been extra more likely to happen earlier than Solana.
“We anticipate a wave of cryptocurrency ETFs subsequent yr, albeit not . First out is probably going the BTC + ETH combo ETFs, then prob Litecoin (bc its fork of btc = commodity), then HBAR (bc not labeled safety) after which XRP/Solana (which have been labeled securities in pending lawsuits),” Balchunas stated.
Balchunas additional defined that complicated authorized points round Solana, referring to its standing as a safety, should be resolved earlier than it may possibly acquire ETF approval. Consequently, he deemed the approval of Litecoin or Hedera ETFs extra possible.
Uncertainty over whether or not Solana classifies as a safety is a serious driver fueling doubts over its ETF approval.
Safety Classification Issues
Martins Benkitis, co-founder and CEO of Gravity, defined that Solana’s regulatory classification complicates its path to approval.
“It’s no secret there’s at the moment a lack of precedent for Layer-1 blockchains past Bitcoin and Ethereum in the ETF area, this suggests cautious optimism however with larger regulatory hurdles. Bitcoin, being a commodity within the SEC’s eyes, and Ethereum’s gradual transition to PoS had completely different authorized concerns. Solana, however, faces considerations over potential classification as a safety due to its token distribution and basis’s involvement,” Benkitis informed BeInCrypto.
The SEC recognized Solana as a safety in lawsuits in opposition to Binance and Coinbase over the previous two years, though these lawsuits have since been dropped. The SEC argued that these tokens might be thought of funding contracts underneath the Howey Take a look at.
Whereas some interpreted the SEC’s lawsuit withdrawal as a softening stance on Solana’s safety classification, others rapidly challenged this assumption.
“There is no such thing as a purpose to assume [the] SEC has determined SOL is a non-security. That they don’t need to do discovery on a dozen tokens within the Binance case seems to be a litigation tactic, not a change in coverage,” stated Jake Chervinsky, Chief Authorized Officer at Variant, following the Binance lawsuit withdrawal in July 2024.
Others consider {that a} pro-crypto administration must be sufficient to affect the SEC to think about Solana as a non-security. Lai disagrees.
“The altering political panorama, notably with Trump’s victory and pro-crypto stance, might create a extra constructive atmosphere for progressive blockchain platforms like Solana. Nonetheless, the technical and market construction concerns will stay essential no matter administration adjustments,” he stated.
Within the meantime, there are a number of different necessities Solana should meet.
Necessities Past Market Demand
In figuring out whether or not an ETF is match for approval, the SEC requires the product to meet strict regulatory requirements. These embody compliance and adherence to present monetary rules, ample market demand from institutional and retail traders, dependable custody options, excessive liquidity ranges, and rigorous asset efficiency and governance transparency.
On his half, Lai added different points to the listing of concerns.
“Whereas Polymarket exhibits excessive odds for 2025 approval, a number of vital components counsel a extra complicated pathway: Solana’s technological structure presents distinctive challenges with its PoS mechanism; The absence of CME futures raises liquidity and threat administration considerations; Historic community downtime incidents want addressing; Centralization questions relative to BTC and ETH stay unresolved; Institutional curiosity hasn’t matched BTC and ETH ranges regardless of the community driving 48% of worldwide DEX quantity; [and] the momentary nature of trending themes suggests warning in utilizing present volumes as major indicators,” Lai informed BeInCrypto.
Issues about centralization and scalability have lengthy been mentioned concerning Solana, even exterior of discussions over an ETF approval.
Addressing Community Reliability
In sure points, Solana faces extra obstacles than in the case of Bitcoin and Ethereum, one of which is market manipulation.
Since 2021, Solana has suffered over a dozen community outages various in severity. These outages have jeopardized the community’s status as secure and dependable– two strongly thought of traits through the ETF approval course of.
“From a market making standpoint, community reliability is essential as any downtime or congestion can considerably influence buying and selling operations and order execution,” Benkitis affirmed.
Nonetheless, Solana has efficiently curbed the variety of outages it has skilled. As soon as infamous for the frequency of its shutdowns, the final time Solana skilled one was in February 2024.
In the meantime, builders designed Solana’s upcoming Firedancer validator consumer to enhance community stability and transaction processing. Its distinct codebase provides higher resilience in opposition to widespread outages and can improve Solana’s efficiency.
But, Solana should additionally mitigate centralization considerations to enhance its possibilities of acquiring ETF approval.
Centralization Issues
Solana’s validator node necessities, which demand vital {hardware} investments, can create limitations to entry. These obstacles can probably focus energy inside the community amongst these able to affording the required infrastructure.
In flip, the protocol’s restricted variety of validators in comparison with different networks raises considerations over centralization. For context, whereas Solana at the moment has round 2,000 energetic validators, Ethereum handed the a million benchmark final yr—the most important quantity recorded by any blockchain community.
Although Solana’s {hardware} reliance hastens the community, it additionally raises decentralization considerations. Benkitis factored this side into his analysis of an ETF approval.
“Robust institutional demand can bolster Solana’s case, offering extra liquidity and market depth, which market makers will welcome with open arms, however it may not be sufficient to counterbalance regulatory considerations surrounding safety classifications and centralisation,” he stated.
Different concerns additionally stay.
Futures Market Infrastructure and Volatility
Its at the moment underdeveloped futures market infrastructure additional complicates Solana’s viability as an ETF candidate.
Its filings have been unprecedented as a result of the community did not have a beforehand established futures market. This issue was essential in figuring out an ETF approval for Bitcoin and Ethereum.
“The shortage of CME futures and institutional frameworks corresponding to BTC/ETH might affect [the SEC’s] analysis,” Lai stated.
He added that the proliferation of meme tokens minted on Solana might current themselves as a possible roadblock.
“Market reactions mirror Solana’s emergence as the first driver of this cycle, with DEX volumes exceeding $100 billion and dominating main aggregators. Nonetheless, I consider the momentary nature of trending themes suggests continued volatility. Whereas technological development and rising institutional adoption might present stronger foundations, we have to keep perspective on the cyclical nature of crypto traits,” Lai stated.
This more moderen improvement in Solana’s attraction additionally brings its set of downsides.
Meme Coin Affect and Regulatory Issues
The increasing meme coin market on Solana partially explains its reputation. Platforms like Pump.enjoyable permit anybody to launch their tokens, and this design has even led to celebrities launching their tokens on the platform.
Extra not too long ago, political figures like Donald Trump and Argentine president Javier Milei have additionally launched meme tokens on Solana platforms. But, these actions have confirmed to be high-risk. In lots of circumstances, meme coin investments have brought on smaller retailers thousands and thousands of {dollars} in losses.
Benkitis stated that the SEC may frown upon the speculative nature of those buying and selling actions.
“Whereas an ETF approval might unlock liquidity alternatives, the market’s heavy dependence on speculative sentiment requires a measured and cautious method,” he stated.
With so many concerns, approving a Solana ETF in 2025 is much from assured. The SEC’s eventual determination can be a defining second for the community and the broader crypto trade.
Disclaimer
Following the Belief Challenge pointers, this function article presents opinions and views from trade consultants or people. BeInCrypto is devoted to clear reporting, however the views expressed on this article don’t essentially mirror these of BeInCrypto or its employees. Readers ought to confirm data independently and seek the advice of with an expert earlier than making choices based mostly on this content material. Please notice that our Phrases and Situations, Privateness Coverage, and Disclaimers have been up to date.