The leisure trade’s battle with the AI trade continued on Tuesday, with over 400 entertainers—together with Mark Ruffalo, Paul McCartney, Cynthia Erivo, Cate Blanchett, and Chris Rock—signed an open letter urging the Trump administration to uphold present copyright protections in opposition to AI coaching practices.
The letter comes after Google and OpenAI requested that such legal guidelines be relaxed. In February, the Trump Administration known as for public feedback on a man-made intelligence motion plan that the White Home stated would outline “precedence coverage actions” concerning the U.S. place within the world AI trade.
“We firmly consider that America’s world AI management should not come on the expense of our important inventive industries,” the letter stated. “America’s arts and leisure trade helps over 2.3 million American jobs with over $229 billion in wages yearly, whereas offering the muse for American democratic affect and comfortable energy overseas.”
The letter, signed by a consortium of leisure trade luminaries—together with Star Wars: The Final Jedi director Rian Johnson, actresses Aubrey Plaza and Carrie Coon, and Thor: Ragnarok director Taika Waititi—was a response to honest use proposals by OpenAI and Google.
In a press release to Decrypt, a Google spokesperson emphasised that the present honest use framework gives a stable authorized basis for innovation.
“We assist America’s present honest use framework, and we’re assured that present copyright regulation allows AI innovation,” the spokesperson stated.
Decrypt additionally reached out to OpenAI for remark however didn’t instantly obtain a response.
Critics argue that broadening the U.S. honest use doctrine—which allows restricted use of copyrighted materials with out having to first purchase permission from the copyright holder—to cowl AI builders would threaten the leisure trade and different sectors.
“Make no mistake: This problem goes effectively past the leisure trade, as the correct to coach AI on all copyright-protected content material impacts all of America’s data industries,” the letter stated. “When tech and AI firms demand unfettered entry to all knowledge and knowledge, they’re not simply threatening motion pictures, books, and music, however the work of all writers, publishers, photographers, scientists, and all different professionals who work with computer systems and generate mental property.”
OpenAI famous SB-1047, the California invoice launched in 2024 by State Senator Scott Wiener, proposing {that a} sandbox be created to supply legal responsibility protections from “state-based rules that concentrate on frontier mannequin safety.”
Decrypt contacted Wiener’s officer for remark, however didn’t instantly obtain a response.
“This may assist preserve the U.S. private and non-private sectors aggressive by permitting AI firms of all sizes to pursue bleeding-edge AI expertise, free from the regulatory uncertainty created by some state-based legal responsibility regimes,” the corporate wrote.
Handed in August, SB-1047 aimed to control the event and deployment of superior synthetic intelligence—also known as frontier fashions—to mitigate potential catastrophic dangers related to misuse.
If OpenAI and Google efficiently have the honest use doctrine augmented to cowl AI builders, it may go a great distance in serving to to win the authorized battles writers, artists, and media retailers have mounted in opposition to the trade since AI surged into the mainstream in 2022.
Edited by James Rubin
Usually Clever Publication
A weekly AI journey narrated by Gen, a generative AI mannequin.