A pseudonymous defendant has moved to dismiss a New York lawsuit searching for possession of 39,069 dormant Bitcoin addresses, arguing that Bitcoin addresses are merely information strings that can not be sued.
The defendant, figuring out themselves as “John Doe 33,” filed a discover of look and movement to dismiss on Thursday, claiming they management one of many dormant wallets named within the lawsuit.
In accordance with the movement, the lawsuit is legally faulty as a result of Bitcoin handle strings are neither individuals nor authorized entities topic to the court docket’s jurisdiction. The submitting argues {that a} public Bitcoin handle can not itself be “discovered” underneath New York’s lost-property legislation as a result of it has all the time been publicly seen on the blockchain.
The submitting challenges the lawsuit filed in Might by plaintiff “Noah Doe” and two Wyoming-based LLCs, ABC Firm and XYZ Firm. The plaintiffs declare the Bitcoin tied to the listed addresses constitutes deserted property that they reported to the New York Police Division and claimed underneath New York lost-property legislation.
No matter how the court docket guidelines on possession, it stays unclear how the plaintiffs may recuperate any Bitcoin with out possessing the personal keys wanted to entry the wallets.
Defendant recordsdata a movement to dismiss the case searching for possession of 39,069 Bitcoin wallets. Supply: iapps.court docket.state.ny.us
The criticism lists 39,069 Bitcoin addresses, together with pockets addresses broadly related to Bitcoin creator Satoshi Nakamoto and the Mt. Gox hacker. The listed wallets collectively maintain an estimated 3.7 million BTC (price about $234 billion), based on Sani, founding father of Bitcoin analytics platform Timechain Index.
Associated: Bitcoin miner MARA spent $4.3M on CEO safety in 2025 as crypto assaults rise
Defendant seems to regulate $300 million Bitcoin pockets
Blockchain information means that “John Doe 33” controls a pockets holding 5,000 BTC acquired in April 2014 that has remained untouched for greater than 12 years, making it price greater than $300 million at present costs, based on a Friday X publish from Galaxy Digital head of analysis Alex Thorn.
“That is ~100x the median defendant handle. It is a actual holder with actual standing selecting to combat, not a bystander.”
Supply: Alex Thorn
Thorn added that the submitting prevented what had been a “near-certain” default judgment and challenged jurisdictional and statutory defects within the plaintiffs’ case.
The availability of Bitcoin has been dormant for the previous 5 and 10 years. Supply: Bitbo
There are presently 3.5 million BTC, price about $215 billion, which were dormant for the previous 10 years and one other 6.6 million cash, price round $406 billion, which were dormant for over 5 years, Bitbo information exhibits.
Journal: How crypto legal guidelines modified in 2025 — and the way they’ll change in 2026